County grants right to photocopy financial disclosure forms

Straus News wins freedom of information appeal: county attorney says ethics code update will make disclosure forms more accessible


Make text smaller Make text larger



Photos



  • Straus News looks at disclosure forms at the current county board of ethics office at 15 Matthews St. in Goshen. From left: Alexis Tarazzi, features editor; Pamela Chergotis, managing editor of The Chronicle; Hema Easely, investigative reporter; and Susan Wynn, account executive.



— The Orange County attorney has granted The Chronicle, sister paper to The Warwick Advertiser, its request for photocopied financial disclosure forms that the county's board of ethics had earlier denied.

County Attorney Langdon Chapman went even further, saying that the county's code of ethics will be revised to allow the photocopying of disclosure forms, and that the county would even post them online.

County officials are now reviewing the current ethics code, which expressly forbids the photographing or photocopying of the financial disclosure forms that appointed and elected county officials are obliged to complete every year. The lawyer for the board of ethics, Donald Nichol, told The Chronicle in April that while the disclosure forms may be inspected and their contents copied by hand, they could not be photographed or photocopied.

Laura Handman, the lawyer representing the newspapers in the Straus News group, appealed to county attorney Langdon Chapman. She said state law, upheld in court, subjects local ethics boards to the Freedom of Information Law (FOIL), and that state law trumps local law. She quoted a previous ruling that said the “inspection and copying of annual financial statements, including the source of the official’s income and a delineation of investments, is the very type of information that the public has the right to uncover when looking into conflicts of interest.”

Chapman answered the appeal on June 16. "I am of the opinion that the current Orange County Ethics Law...is unenforceable to the extent that it expressly prohibits photocopying of the County Ethics Form," he said.

The county executive and district attorney in February announced their intention to update the ethics code after Legislator Leigh Benton accepted, and soon after rejected, a job with an architectural firm that had been hired by a legislative committee he headed.

Chapman said that before the new code is adopted, "I am constrained...not to release any more than is required to be released, given the language of the present County Law."

He further said that the county in revising its law "would conform the County Law to the State Law with respect to making these Ethics Forms public, and in fact require them generally to be posted online."

Handman represents numerous news organizations in their First Amendment and freedom of information matters. "Copies will enhance accuracy of reporting about such important information about public officials," she had said in arguing The Chronicle's case.

- Pamela Chergotis

Make text smaller Make text larger

Comments

Pool Rules



MUST READ NEWS

Trying to make a difference, one ornament at a time
— Jillian Disy says that one day she’d like to be an engineer. She’s not sure what kind of engineer, but she knows...
Read more »
Image

Mount Peter prepares to kick off 2017-18 season this Saturday
— With the recent snow and a week of solid snowmaking, Mount Peter Ski Area, for skiing, snowboarding and snow tubing, kicks off...
Read more »
Image

Chosun Taekwondo Academy celebrates 20th anniversary
— The Chosun Taekwondo Academy, a local martial arts and hatha yoga center located at 60 Galloway Road in Warwick, hosting its 20th...
Read more »
Image

The miracle of light
— It had been raining lightly and a bit on the chilly side but on Tuesday evening, Dec. 12, a crowd of about 75 residents gathered...
Read more »
Image

VIDEOS



E-NEWSLETTER

Sign up to get our newsletter emailed to you every week!

  • Enter your email address in the box below.
  • Select the newsletters you would like to subscribe to.
  • Click the 'SUBSCRIBE' button.

* indicates required
Community Newspapers


MOST READ

MOST COMMENTED



Warwick, NY